• Home
  • Podcast
    • Specials
  • Interviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • TV Reviews
  • DVD Reviews
  • Columns
  • News
    • TV News
    • Film News
    • DVD News
    • Online Entertainment News
    • Space News
    • Music News
    • On Stage
    • Geeky, Funny & Weird

Slice of SciFi

This is How We Geek Out: Interviews, Reviews & More

  • Writers, After Dark
  • The Babylon Podcast
  • Slice of SciFi TV
  • Charlie Jade Verse
  • Contact Us
    • About Us
“Doctor Who: Amy’s Choice” — A Slice of SciFi Review

“Doctor Who: Amy’s Choice” — A Slice of SciFi Review

May 17, 2010 By Michael Hickerson 4 Comments

amyschoiceWhen he took over the reigns as show runner, Steven Moffat said that in his mind, “Doctor Who” was the story of the companion and their journey through time and space. No where is that more evident than in the latest installment of the modern series, “Amy’s Choice.”

“Amy’s Choice” is about the title character growing up and being forced to choose between her two men–the fantasy man she’s dreamed of since she was a child in the Doctor and Rory, the more down to Earth man who wants to settle down with her and build a life together.

And in order to do this, Amy is presented with two possible scenarios and told that one is a dream and the other reality. If she dies in the dream world, she wakes up in the real one. If she dies in the real world, she dies entirely, as do the Doctor and Rory.

One possibility finds the Doctor, Rory and Amy trapped in the TARDIS, falling into a cold star and slowly freezing to death. The other finds Amy and Rory married, living in a village where Rory is now a doctor and they’re expecting their first child. The Doctor turns up for a visit and soon discovers there’s something sinister going on in the village.

Into this comes a mysterious figure called the Dream Lord, who presents the scenario to the TARDIS crew. The trio shuffle back and forth by falling asleep in one reality to the tweeting of birds. Interestingly, time passes in each scenario while the various players are asleep, giving the final moments of their episode a ticking clock to ratchet up the intensity of things as Amy is forced to choose one reality over other other.

As with all the other stories of the Moffat era (so far), what “Amy’s Choice” gives us is an interesting idea fully explored and expanded to its fullest. Watching both realities unfold, there are arguments for and against both being the real world and the dream world. And seeing Amy forced to choose between them is nicely done, especially given the tension from last week’s storyline between the Doctor and Rory and the way in which Amy announced she was content having her “two boys” at the conclusion of events last week.

The choice, and more importantly how Amy arrives at the choice, is a fascinating one, especially given the implications of who and what the Dream Lord is. The story does a nice job of offering hints that the Doctor’s knows who the Dream Lord is and then paying that off in the end. It also has some fascinating implications and a nice potential homage to one of the more intriguing villains of the classic series.

The convention of having various elements from a typical “Doctor Who” story play into each scenario is also nicely done. In many ways, the story serves as a commentary on the typical aspects of what makes a “Doctor Who” story and serves as a bit of a satire of the program itself. It’s similar to what the “X-Files” did with classic episodes like “Jose Chung’s ‘From Outer Space'” or “Clyde Bruckman’s Final Repose.” By examining the conventions of the show, you get a greater understanding of the characters.

And the implications of who the Dream Lord is are fascinating and hopefully a threat Mofatt will pick up again in the future. (If you’re a classic series fan, you may find yourself thinking of the Valeyard….I certainly did).

Once again, Moffat and his writing team, deliver a solid, fascinating and compelling episode. It’s helped greatly by solid performances by Matt Smith and Karen Gillian as well as solid work by Arthur Darvill as Rory. In many cases, Darvill steals the show with his nuanced work as Rory here.

Certainly the script pushes Rory out of the shadow of Mickey and makes him something more interesting. Rory may be the best male companion the new show has produced.

And then, there’s the preview for next week…the story I am most looking forward to seeing.

Filed Under: TV Reviews Tagged With: Doctor Who

About Michael Hickerson

Michael was a contributor to Slice of SciFi, as both a news curator and assistant editor, under the tutelage of former News Director Sam Sloan.

Related Posts

“Doctor Who: The Rebel Flesh” — A Slice of SciFi Review
“Doctor Who: The Beast Below” — A Slice of SciFi Review
BBC America Sets “Doctor Who” Return

Comments

  1. TallGrrl says

    May 18, 2010 at 5:32 pm

    I really liked this episode.
    No. I LOVED this episode.
    This show this season has raised the bar with each episode, and cleared it with room to spare.
    The wacky, zany, sexy (yep!), intriguing Doctor has done some not-so-cool things in his life/lives. And he remembers them all.
    There’s no one in the universe that hates The Doctor…more than himself.
    He had to take Amy to a very dark and hurtful place in order to make her come to terms with growing up and past being The Little Girl Who Waited.
    There’s still plenty of funny and wacky in this episode, but, as The Doctor would say, “There are some cowboys in there.”
    I highly recommend the Confidential for this episode. It’s called “Arthurian Legends” and Arthur Darvill (who really stepped up in this episode) “hosts”.

  2. TallGrrl says

    May 18, 2010 at 5:34 pm

    Oh!
    And right on with your assessment of Rory.
    I loved Mikey, but unlike Mikey, Rory has already won: Amy has chosen him over The Doctor.

  3. fred says

    May 21, 2010 at 4:31 am

    Great episode and it’s nice to have that particular storyline end sooner than later.

    Run? One of us is pregs!

  4. maria says

    June 1, 2010 at 8:20 pm

    why oh why does my BBC America on demand only have 3 episodes, none of which are the new ones! i’m trying so hard to catch up. oh, and why did BBC america skip an episode?! anyone know if these are available online?

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts

Slice

Follow Slice of SciFi

  • bluesky
  • twitter
  • youtube
  • facebook

Listen to Slice of SciFi

  • iheartradio
  • pocketcasts
  • playerfm

Subscribe to Podcast

Apple PodcastsSpotifyiHeartRadioPodchaserTuneInRSS

TV Sci-Fi Deals

  • Movie & TV Reviews

Recent Comments

  • Summer Brooks on DVD Review: “Ben 10: The Complete Collection” mostly isn’t complete: “From what I recall of the previous Warner Archive sets, the Super Friends Complete Collection and the Captain Planet Complete…”
  • Andrés on DVD Review: “Ben 10: The Complete Collection” mostly isn’t complete: “I would’ve loved a Blu-ray release of the shows and the movies.”
  • Summer Brooks on Humble Bundle: The Essential “Star Wars Insider” Collection: “I’m sad to hear that those were indeed Kobo only. I had emailed in, asking if they were Kobo or…”
  • Joe Stevensus on Humble Bundle: The Essential “Star Wars Insider” Collection: “Update Humble Bundle refunded quickly and easily. So kudos to them for that.”
  • Joe Stevensus on Humble Bundle: The Essential “Star Wars Insider” Collection: “You need Kobo to read them and it just downloads a tiny file (1.5 k file). I don’t want to…”
death to humans 160x600
mass x acceleration

Slice of SciFi
415 Pisgah Church Rd #302
Greensboro NC 27455-2590
602-635-6976

Artwork:
Slice of SciFi galaxy spiral designed by Tim Callender

Theme Music:
Slice of SciFi music and themes
courtesy of Sci-Fried

Sister Sites:
Writers, After Dark
The Babylon Podcast
Charlie Jade Verse
Slice of SciFi TV

Slice

Copyright Slice of SciFi © 2005–2025 · WordPress · Log in