• Home
  • Podcast
    • Specials
  • Interviews
  • Movie Reviews
  • TV Reviews
  • DVD Reviews
  • Columns
  • News
    • TV News
    • Film News
    • DVD News
    • Comics News
    • Online Entertainment News
    • Music News
    • Book News
    • Space News

Slice of SciFi

This is How We Geek Out: Interviews, Reviews & More

  • Writers, After Dark
  • The Babylon Podcast
  • Slice of SciFi TV
  • Charlie Jade Verse
  • Contact Us
    • About Us

Doctor Who: “42” Review

May 21, 2007 By Michael Hickerson 5 Comments

42.jpgStories in which the events that happen on-screen take the same amount of time as the audience spends invested in the film or television program are nothing new. It happened in the classic “High Noon” (the original, not any of the substandard remakes) and viewers can see it unfolding each week on the hit series “24.”

But to have a story unfold in “real time” is something new and different for “Doctor Who” and something that couldn’t have effectively happened in the original series. Building to a cliffhanger every 24 or so minutes wouldn’t have allowed the “real time” concept to work quite as effectively as it does here.

So, it’s interesting that even though the central hook of “42” is something that could only happen on the new series, the episode itself would be firmly grounded in the conventions of the classic series. And that this hybrid of new and old would make for one of the most effective and entertaining stories of series three and David Tennant’s run as the Doctor.

The Doctor and Martha arrive on a space-ship in the near-future. The ship is crashing into a near-by star and has 42 minutes before the they plummet into the system’s sun and perish. The Doctor figures he can load everyone into the TARDIS and they can escape–except the TARDIS is cut-off by the heat overload.

To make things worse, a mysterious force is possessing members of the crew and burning those who come into contact with it to death.

The concept of having the Doctor separated from the TARDIS and forced into taking part in the events unfolding on screen is something that harkens all the way back to the early days of the classic show. There were many stories that involved the central dilemma of finding a way back to the TARDIS or being separate from the time machine.

But the new hook is the “real time” concept being used for the story. It heightens the suspense of the story and drives the narrative forward, giving us a ticking time clock that the Doctor and the crew of the spaceship must beat or meet their utltimate demise.

Along the way, there are some really great scenes from a character standpoint, including Martha’s being trapped in a life support pod and jettisoned off the ship, Martha’s calling home to her mother to say goodbye and the Doctor becoming possessed by the sun. Not to sound repititive here, but David Tennant really delivers again this week as the Doctor. He’s still got the energy of series two, but he’s more controlled and less manic about it–and it shows in his performance. The scenes where the Doctor desparately tries to save Martha and then becomes possessed by the alien intelligence are some of the best work he’s done on the show.

And, for the most part, the supporting cast do a good job as well. A lot of them are there as canon fodder for the possessed humans to kill off, but the few that do get some screen time come off well. The only exception is Michelle Collins as the ship’s captain. It’s hard to believe she’s a tough as nails as the script would like us to believe.

And I’d be remiss in pointing out that, for the most part, this is essentially the same concept we saw last year in “The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit” two-parter. But despite being a bit derivative, the story is still entertaining, exciting, well acted and the visuals are stunning.

All that and I haven’t even addressed the phone calls from Martha to her mother. It seems that following the events of “The Lazarus Experiment” Matha’s mother has been pursuaded by Mr. Saxon’s aid to assist them. They listen in on the conversations between Martha and her mother…but for what purpose, we’re not quite sure yet. After last year’s being hit over the head by a two-by-four lack of subtelty with “Torchwood,” it’s nice to see the show can drop hints and have a season-long arc that doesn’t feel forced.

So, after a two-week hiatus, “Doctor Who” returns with a sold, well done hybrid of the new and the old. A good step and it certainly has me excited for next week’s installment–the long-awaited small screen adaptation of the classic New Adventure, “Human Nature.”

Filed Under: TV Reviews Tagged With: Doctor Who

About Michael Hickerson

Michael was a contributor to Slice of SciFi, as both a news curator and assistant editor, under the tutelage of former News Director Sam Sloan.

Related Posts

Doctor Who Season 9
TV Talk: “Doctor Who” Season 9 Recap
Who Does Smith Want Back for the 50th Anniversary?
“Day of the Doctor” Sets Alternative Content Cinema Record

Comments

  1. PaulJ says

    May 21, 2007 at 10:47 pm

    I enjoyed “42”, but I was expecting a Douglas Adams reference. Did I miss it?

    And that red helmet — I couldn’t help thinking of Frederator.

  2. Chunky says

    May 22, 2007 at 11:10 am

    Yet another cheap as shit unoriginal episode with Mr. goggle-eyed scream machine doing his best to do just that. Not one question about how these two people arrived on the ship heading for the sun, they just accept his help. This season has been crappier than ever. Jeez you Americans love anything from England don’t you?

  3. Michael in Nashville says

    May 22, 2007 at 5:52 pm

    Don’t hold bank, Chunky…tell us how you really feel.

    I stand by the review. I enjoyed the episode and found it very entertaining.

  4. TheRooster says

    May 23, 2007 at 1:52 am

    Personally I felt the similarity between this episode and the Satan’s Pit double last season just spoilt it for me… and I preferred The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit… as bad as the acting was

  5. David says

    May 28, 2007 at 12:23 am

    I thought it was OK. Maybe a bit too similar to the Satan Pit. I think I’ll enjoy it more a second time, because I only spotted the real-time aspect 30 minutes in. (D’oh!)

    And, of course, PaulJ, the Title ’42’ was a nod towards ’24’ because, like ’24’, the events unfold in real time.

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts

Slice

Follow Slice of SciFi

  • youtube
  • bluesky
  • twitter
  • facebook

Listen to Slice of SciFi

  • iheartradio
  • pocketcasts
  • playerfm

Subscribe to Podcast

Apple PodcastsSpotifyiHeartRadioPodchaserPodcast IndexTuneInRSS

  • Movie & TV Reviews

Recent Comments

  • Kristen on Journal Now Interview With “Surface” Co-Creator: “I was just talking about this in the car this morning, not for the first time. I grew up watching…”
  • Xander Rohrig on Check Out the Cupcake Games: “its dig dug”
  • Curt Myers on 4K Review: “Dogma” 25th Anniversary Special Edition brings a lost classic home again: “The best the movie has looked. It’s dialogue heavy so the Atmos track is rarely used. When it comes in…”
  • Summer Brooks on “FATE: The Winx Saga” writer Olivia Cuartero-Briggs talks adapting properties: “I requested it. I always get a little curious when TV shows or films get abandoned or canceled then continue…”
  • anh on “FATE: The Winx Saga” writer Olivia Cuartero-Briggs talks adapting properties: “Great interview! And it’s good that it clarifies some things. But this interview…. was it requested by the publisher or…”
Neil deGrasse Tyson Bill Nye

Slice of SciFi
415 Pisgah Church Rd #302
Greensboro NC 27455-2590
602-635-6976

Artwork:
Slice of SciFi galaxy spiral designed by Tim Callender

Theme Music:
Slice of SciFi music and themes
courtesy of Sci-Fried

Sister Sites:
Writers, After Dark
The Babylon Podcast
Charlie Jade Verse
Slice of SciFi TV

Slice

Copyright Slice of SciFi © 2005–2026 · WordPress · Log in